
Join today and save! Use code Guest2Member15 for 15% off your membership.
If you have an existing account with us, please login before making a purchase.
Have you ever noticed how you talk to yourself when you make a mistake or perceive a flaw? Maybe you say something awkward at a party and spend the rest of the evening replaying what an idiot you are. Or you look in the mirror and your comments are so brutal they would make a professional wrestler blush. We often say things to ourselves that we’d never dream of saying to anyone else, let alone someone we cared about.
The strange thing is that we usually believe our inner critic. When it tells us we’re lazy, ugly, selfish, or inadequate, we tend to assume it’s telling the truth. We forget that our minds have a strong negativity bias, exquisitely tuned by evolution to notice what’s wrong and overlook what’s right. This helped our ancestors survive in a dangerous world. But when this negativity bias turns inward in the form of self-criticism, it tends to fuel anxiety and depression while undermining our motivation.
Our inner critic often has good intentions, even if its methods leave something to be desired. It’s trying to keep us from making mistakes, disappointing others, or being rejected. It worries that without its constant nagging, we’d never improve, be accepted by others, or be safe.
But being imperfect doesn’t mean we’re failures. Our worth doesn’t depend on getting everything right or living up to some idealized version of who we think we should be. Our worth is intrinsic to our flawed, messy humanity. When we can accept ourselves as we are, we have a more secure foundation from which to learn and grow.
The tricky part is that we don’t want to simply tell our inner critic to shut up or try to get rid of it. That would just create another internal battle. Instead, it’s more helpful to become more aware of our critical self-talk and understand the fears that lie underneath it. We can then try to respond to ourselves in a kinder and more encouraging manner.
For example, instead of saying, “You’re so stupid for making that mistake,” you could try, “I know you’re upset because you wanted things to go well. Everyone makes mistakes sometimes. Knowing what you know now, what might you do differently next time?”
Exercise:
I invite you to try the written exercise, Changing Your Critical Self-Talk, over the course of a few days. The first step is to notice when you’re being self-critical and write down what your inner critic is saying. The second is to acknowledge what your inner critic is worried about. The final step is to try to rephrase its message in a more helpful and supportive way.
Don’t worry if your compassionate voice feels awkward or unnatural at first. After years of practicing self-criticism, it takes time to develop a different habit. And if you find yourself being critical about how self-critical you are, that’s okay too. Just another opportunity to practice self-compassion!
Steve Hickman is a co-developer of the Mindful Self-Compassion Teacher Training, a retired clinical psychologist and the Founding Director of the UC San Diego Center for Mindfulness. Steve has taught self-compassion and mindfulness across the globe, and is the author of Self-Compassion for Dummies.
We’d love you to welcome him. You can register ahead of time, or just drop in!
Scholarship Rates